Buy the tray that matches the number of plants you will actually prick out
Seed starting trays are a place where generosity gets expensive. A stack of 72-cell flats looks cheap per cell until you realize you have neither the light nor the weekdays to water seventy-two seedlings. The economical question is not “which tray is best in general?” It is “how many plants will I transplant, and can each of them leave this tray with its own roots intact?”
University of Minnesota Extension’s guide to starting seeds indoors is plain on the container itself: start in small, individual cells rather than sowing a crowd in one open tub, because roots grow into each other and suffer when you tease them apart. Every container needs drainage holes. A windowsill is a poor default location — temperatures swing, mixes dry or stay cold, and seedlings often grow tall and lean. Plan for a space you can keep reasonably warm, and for light you can put close to the plants, not for a pretty row on a sash.
Use that official advice as the frame, and then spend only on the trays, domes, and mix that support it. Your local Cooperative Extension office can add dates and varieties for your frost calendar.
A comparison table for the tray aisle
| Option | What you are paying for | A good use | A poor use |
|---|---|---|---|
| A divided cell flat that fits a standard tray | Separate root balls, easy watering from below if the tray is watertight, a known footprint under lights | Most vegetables and flowers you will pot on later | Filling every cell “because they came in 72s” when you need twelve plants |
| Small individual pots | A little more soil and a slightly longer stay before potting on | Larger seeds, or plants you already know grow fast | Buying decorative pots with no drainage because they looked sturdy |
| An open sowing flat or a reused food tray | A cheap place to germinate, if you will prick out early | A few species you are happy to transplant at the seedling stage | Leaving a forest of roots to turn into one felted mat |
| A seed starting tray with a dome | Higher humidity while seeds germinate | The first days, with the dome cracked or off once droplets and mold appear | Leaving a sealed dome over a sunny, hot tray until the seedlings cook |
| Reusable heavy plastic cells | Many seasons, if you wash them | A yearly habit of starting seeds | A one-season experiment you will not repeat; the cheap disposable flat may be enough this year |
| A silicone seed starting tray | Flexibility and washing, in some designs | Small batches you can pop out gently | Assuming “silicone” replaces drainage, or using it as a reason to skip a proper mix |
| Peat, paper, or other “plantable” pots | A container you can, in theory, set in the ground | Only if you will bury the rim, as Extension warns: a rim left above the soil can wick water away from the roots | Paying extra and then standing the pot proud of the soil, which defeats the point |
| A homemade DIY seed starting tray | Yogurt cups or similar, with holes you punched | A small, first year, if the cups are clean and stable | A wobbly collection that tips under lights and cannot be watered from below |
Drainage is not a feature. It is the minimum. A tray that holds a swamp in the bottom of each cell will cost you plants, which is the dearest way to save a dollar on plastic.
How to choose size, mix, and extras without a special shop
Cell size should let the seedling grow to transplant or pot-on stage without circulating in a huge volume of unused mix. Very large cells waste media and space under lights. Very tiny cells dry out faster than a busy household will notice. If you start tomatoes, peppers, or other plants that sit indoors for several weeks, plan a pot-on step, not one heroic cell that is meant to last until June.
Buy a mix made for starting seeds, which is usually finer and lower in nutrients than a chunky potting soil. Garden soil in a tray is a good way to import damping-off trouble. You do not need a different branded mix for every vegetable. You do need enough mix to fill the cells you will actually sow, plus a little for potting on.
Reusable seed starting trays are worth it when you will wash them. A brush, hot soapy water, and a complete dry-out between seasons is the cheap hygiene program. Cracked cells that will not drain, or that fold in your hand, go in the bin.
A humidity dome is optional. A loose cover, or a clear lid propped open, can help some seeds stay evenly moist until they sprout. Once they are up, they want air more than they want a terrarium. Seed starting trays and domes sold as a set are convenient; they are not mandatory.
Heat mats help some seeds, and they also dry a mix faster. If you use one, you are committing to more frequent checks, not to less work. Lights close above the plants will do more for sturdy stems than a south window that cooks at noon and chills at night, which is exactly the pattern Extension warns about.
A buying-and-use sequence that wastes less mix
- Count the plants you want in the ground, plus a few extras, not a full flat “for luck.”
- Choose divided cells or small pots with holes, in a tray you can pick up without bending.
- Fill with a seed-starting mix, sow at the depth on the packet, and label as you go. Unlabelled trays are how you grow three kinds of “probably tomato.”
- Water so the mix is evenly moist, not floating. Bottom watering helps if the tray allows it.
- As soon as seedlings are up, give them close, strong light and air, and take any dome off or prop it well open.
- Pot on or harden off on a schedule you can keep. A tray of perfect seedlings that never get used is not a saving.
Store leftover seed as Extension suggests: a closed container, cool and dry, with a little desiccant if you have it, and do not buy more than you will sow in two or three years.
A checklist at the shelf
- I know how many plants I will care for, not how many cells are in the pack
- Every cell or pot has drainage
- I have a tray I can water in without flooding the furniture
- The mix is a seed-starting mix, and I have enough of it
- A dome, if I buy one, will come off after germination
- Reusable trays will be washed, not stacked dirty
- Lights and a safe, reasonably warm spot are already in the plan
Questions that save a second trip to the shop
Are reusable trays worth the extra money?
They are if you start seeds most years and will wash them. If this is a one-season trial, a simple, draining flat may be the cheaper teacher. The costly mistake is either: a cupboard of unused heavy trays, or a yearly pile of flimsy ones you cannot clean.
Do I need a dome?
No. You need even moisture until germination, which a cover can help with, and you need air after that. If a dome is included, use it lightly and temporarily.
Can I start seeds in an open tray to save money?
You can germinate that way, then prick out early into cells or pots. What you should not do is let a mass of roots grow into one tangle. The official preference for divided cells exists for that reason.
What about biodegradable pots?
They can work if you treat the rim correctly at planting, trimming or burying it so it does not dry the root ball. If you will not do that, a reusable plastic cell, emptied at transplant time, is often the less wasteful choice in practice, because the plant actually lives.